Call Any Time
(203) 690-1030
(203) 690-1030
(203) 690-1030
When you’re on the road—whether driving your own car, a rented vehicle, or behind the wheel for Uber or Lyft—accidents can happen. And when they do, the last thing you want is confusion about who covers the damage.
If you’ve been involved in a rideshare accident while operating a rental car, you’re not alone in wondering: Does insurance still apply? Who pays for the damages? What are your rights?
At Bert McDowell Injury Law, we’re here to break down the answers—and show you how to protect yourself after a crash.
First things first: let’s clear up how rideshare insurance normally works.
Rideshare companies like Uber and Lyft divide insurance coverage into three phases:
App Off: If the driver is not logged into the app, their personal auto insurance applies. No Uber or Lyft coverage is active.
App On, Waiting for Ride: When the app is active but no ride is accepted yet, the rideshare company provides limited liability coverage.
Ride Accepted to Drop-Off: Once a ride is accepted until the passenger is dropped off, the rideshare company’s full commercial insurance coverage kicks in.
Simple enough when you’re driving your own car. But what if you’re in a rental vehicle? That’s where it gets complicated.
If a rideshare driver is operating a rental vehicle at the time of the crash, coverage can come from several potential sources:
Rental car companies often offer extra coverage options at the counter, including:
Collision Damage Waiver (CDW): Covers physical damage to the rental car.
Supplemental Liability Insurance (SLI): Covers damage you cause to others.
However, most rental agreements prohibit using the vehicle for “commercial purposes” — and yes, rideshare driving counts as commercial use.
If you violated the rental agreement by using the vehicle for rideshare without proper authorization, the rental company’s insurance may deny coverage.
Some personal auto policies extend to rental cars.
But there’s a catch: Many personal policies have exclusions if you are driving for a rideshare service.
If your personal insurer denies coverage, you’ll have to rely on either the rideshare company’s policy or the rental car’s policies (if applicable).
If the driver was “on-duty”—meaning logged into the app or transporting a passenger—Uber and Lyft typically provide coverage.
The type of coverage depends on the phase the driver was in:
Waiting for Ride: Limited liability only.
Transporting Passenger: Full coverage, including liability and uninsured/underinsured motorist protection.
In short: if you were actively working, the rideshare company’s insurance likely applies, even though you were driving a rental.
No matter whose car you’re driving—or riding in—your actions right after the crash matter.
First things first: check yourself, your passengers, and others involved for injuries.
Call emergency services immediately if necessary.
Take photos from multiple angles:
Damage to all vehicles
License plates
Road conditions
Visible injuries
Write down witness information too.
Get:
Driver’s license information
Insurance details
Rideshare app screenshots if possible
Rental car agreement information
Report the accident to the rental car company immediately.
File a report with the rideshare platform (Uber/Lyft apps have built-in crash reporting features).
Inform your personal auto insurer.
File a police report, even if injuries seem minor.
Some injuries take hours—or even days—to fully show symptoms.
Don’t delay getting a full evaluation. It also creates a medical record critical for your claim.
Navigating overlapping insurance policies can feel like solving a Rubik’s Cube blindfolded.
At Bert McDowell Injury Law, we’ll handle the insurance companies, legal filings, and negotiations—so you can focus on getting better.
Determining who is responsible after a rideshare crash involving a rental vehicle isn’t always straightforward.
Several parties could share liability:
The Rideshare Driver: If they caused the crash through negligence.
Rental Car Company: Rare, but possible if the vehicle had pre-existing mechanical issues.
Rideshare Company: If their insurance is triggered due to active duty status.
Bottom line: multiple policies could be triggered, but none of them will volunteer to pay without a fight.
Having a strong legal advocate matters.
Even though coverage may exist, insurance companies often resist paying without a legal battle. Common challenges include:
Denials for Commercial Use Violations: Rental companies may deny coverage because of rideshare driving.
Exclusions in Personal Policies: Many private insurers exclude rideshare accidents.
Disputes Over “App Status”: Whether the rideshare app was active at the time is often contested.
An experienced attorney knows how to demand access to rideshare company logs, phone records, and more to prove your case.
If you’ve been involved in a rideshare accident while driving a rental vehicle, the aftermath can feel like a maze.
Between personal policies, rideshare company policies, and rental agreements, it’s easy to get lost—or worse, get denied compensation you’re entitled to.
The key is simple:
Act fast: Document everything.
Notify the right parties: Rental company, rideshare company, insurers.
Get help: Don’t navigate this alone.
At Bert McDowell Injury Law, we know how to cut through the noise—and make sure you get the justice you deserve.
If you or someone you love has been hurt in a rideshare accident involving a rental vehicle, contact Bert McDowell Injury Law today.
Our experienced personal injury attorneys in Connecticut are ready to fight for you—and we don’t back down when insurance companies play games.
Call (475) 529-2634 now for your free consultation.
You focus on healing. We’ll focus on justice.
